Oct 06 2013

@PraxisReform on London’s Worst Value-for-Money MPs?

random_space_fillerGuest article by @PraxisReform:

Recently, we saw the Independent Parliamentary Standards Authority (IPSA) publish the annualised information on MPs’ expenses and costs, for the period 2012-13.

Now, these figures are often criticised because an MP in the north of England clearly has much higher travel expenses than an MP representing a constituency much closer to Westminster.

However, by extracting the figures for London MPs from the IPSA website and comparing those figures, we have a much more useful subset of data, since those London MPs are likely to be paying roughly the some prices for the items they charge to expenses, and the cost of TFL’s most expensive Travelcard is £3,168 (zones 1-9 including Watford Junction).

Total expenses for MPs in the London area (excluding their staffing payroll) came to £1,572,286.90

Top of the list for London expenses is Enfield North’s Nick de Bois with £52,857.47. Mr de Bois says that that he claims expenses for self-employed members of staff, who are not listed on the IPSA payroll, which has bought him to the head of the list.

Second in the London MPs’ expenses top list is Bromley and Chislehurst’s Bob Neill, with £43,729.60.

Mr Neill receives almost universal criticism for keeping a home in his Bromley & Chislehurst constituency (just a half-hour train ride away the House of Commons) as well as another home (which he claims to be his main residence) in Southend-on-Sea, Essex.

Now, in previous years, Harrow East MP Bob Blackman has been a prominent figure at the top of lists of MPs’ expenses, and this year he doesn’t fail to disappoint, ranking third on the 2012-13 list for total London MPs’ expenses with a claim of £35,237.44, being second on the list for constituency office expenses (£26,007.23) and first on the list for travel and subsistence expenses (£4,432.02).

Indeed, the expenses section of Mr Blackman’s own website gives no reason for the amount of expenses that he’s claimed in the past year; nor any attempt to justify his employing his wife Nicola Blackman as his Office Manager (a practise widely condemned during the MPs expenses scandal) on a salary in the £30,000-£34,999 band.

If we put all this into context, in total, Mr Blackman claimed almost £14,000 more than the average London MP, whilst nearby Harrow West MP Gareth Thomas claimed just under £2,500 more than the average London MP, of which he spent only £15 on travel and subsistence, compared to Bob Blackman’s £4,432.02.

Brent North’s Barry Gardiner had the second highest travel and subsistence claim. The second highest amount of travel and subsistence expenses in London (£2,896.55), but even this was just two-thirds of the amount claimed by Bob Blackman.

Other nearby MPs total claims are £21,752.22 claimed by Ruislip, Northwood & Pinner’s Nick Hurd, and just £4,564.20 claimed by Uxbridge and South Ruislip’s John Randall. Barry Gardiner claimed £23,593.55 in total.

In summary, it seems that Bob Blackman is providing spectacularly poor value for money for Harrow East constituents, since it appears that he is spending more of his time travelling, eating and drinking at the public expense, than addressing the problems faced by his Harrow East constituents.

All information was obtained from the IPSA website: http://www.parliamentary-standards.org.uk/


(Visited 5 times, 1 visits today)


Skip to comment form

  1. j p hobbs

    Wow where do I sign on for one of these jobs, no wonder The UK is in debt . I will work day and night for that sort of money and all weekend .

  2. Melanie

    The expenses claimed would seem about right to me. In Harrow East we are blessed with Bob Blackman, who is tireless in his support of residents, who are fed up after years of a local Labour/Independent Labour administration. If Mr Blackman had not been forced to go to the civic centre daily to point out to the then Cabinet, which part of their anatomy was their a**e and which was their elbow, maybe his expenses would have been less. Gareth Thomas’ expenses account for the fact that he couldn’t find Harrow on a map. He proclaims he is an old Harrovian. I drove through Manchester when I was 18, does that make me an old Mancunian. Might I suggest that the Harrow West electorate vote for Hannah David in 2015, then Harrow in its entirety would be looked after by two of the best MPs in Parliament as opposed to Bob Blackman having to clear up the mess in Harrow East and West. Gareth Thomas is not going to run up many expenses sitting on his backside wittering on about when he lived in Harrow (when was it exactly Gareth? 50 years ago, for a fortnight?). If you never do any work then you don’t need to claim any expenses.

  3. j p hobbs

    Sorry how much is a bus ride to the Civic centre ?

  4. Praxis Reform

    It’s not really fair to ask Bob to take the bus. MPs are busy people and buses are usually a pretty shoddy service that rarely turn up on time, and take ages to get anywhere.

    Much better to get him to take the Tube… It’s only an 8 minute journey from Wembley (where Bob lives) to Harrow and Wealdstone, which is right next to the Civic Centre. The fare is only £1.60 for a peak time single (and a bit less if he travels off-peak and/or has an Oyster card).

Comments have been disabled.